Farmers' Perspective on Carnivore Reintroductions


Conservation and Science


Welcome to another issue of the Conservation and Science newsletter. Today, we are discussing an ever-interesting and controversial topic: the restoration of large carnivores, like wolves and lynx, to the islands of Britain and Ireland. To tackle this difficult and complex topic, I welcome to the podcast Jonny Hanson, an environmental social scientist, award-winning social entrepreneur, snow leopard conservationist, and former community farmer. Jonny and his work have been on my radar for a considerable time, and I'm really happy to share our conversation with you.

Farmers' Perspective on Large Carnivore Reintroductions

Can large carnivore conservation coexist with livestock farming? In this episode, environmental social scientist Jonny Hanson and I discuss the complex issue of large carnivore reintroductions in Britain and Ireland. What are farmers' perspectives on sharing landscapes with predators like wolves and lynx? How can we balance conservation goals with the realities of modern agriculture? We explore these pressing questions, drawing from Jonny’s extensive research and firsthand experience as both a researcher and small-scale farmer.

In the episode, we discuss the challenges of large carnivore restoration to landscapes where they've been absent for centuries. Jonny highlights the importance of governance and stakeholder engagement in managing potential conflicts between wildlife and livestock. Our conversation covers various management tools, from livestock guardian dogs to compensation schemes, and examines their practical implications for farmers. Jonny also talks about the need for more social science research to understand the cultural and psychological aspects of reintroductions.

The episode concludes with a thought-provoking discussion on innovative approaches to wildlife management, including the potential use of technology to create "virtual fences" for large carnivores. We also explore the ethical implications of such interventions and question whether they diminish the wildness of reintroduced animals. This episode offers valuable insights into the complexities of rewilding and the delicate balance between conservation and agriculture. Listen to learn how human perspectives shape our future landscapes.

Further Reading:

Jonny's report: Large Carnivore Reintroductions To Britain And Ireland: Farmers’ Perspectives And Management Options

Jonny's article in the Irish Examiner: Why we need to listen to farmers’ perspectives on lynx and wolf reintroductions


Last Week's Replay: Wildlife In The Balance

In his book, “Wildlife in The Balance”, expert ecologist Simon Mustoe lays out the case for animals being the most important ingredient of the ecosystem. He outlines the critical importance of keeping the planet’s energy inputs and outputs in balance and the role animals play in ensuring this balance. This connection of ecology with physics is one of the most unique and forward-thinking aspects of this book. To extend this thought, the book contains one of the most comprehensive and compelling explanations of why the climate crisis and biodiversity crisis are in fact one and the same — neither can be solved separately.


Interintellect Salon: Discount Offer

This weekend, William Mankelow and I are hosting another Interintellect salon. Our topic: media consumption. We'll explore the question, "Have you ever considered consuming less media?"

Reclaiming Your Time and Sanity: The Case for Minimal Media Consumption

Want free VIP seats for this salon and all our future Interintellect events? Become a member of the Conservation and Science community on Buy Me a Coffee.

Subscribe now to enjoy exclusive benefits and join thought-provoking discussions!

I strive to deliver the most interesting and educational conversations with the most engaging guests about the natural environment. It is my goal to continue to deliver this content at no cost to you. However, the production of the podcast requires a significant investment of time and money. So I would appreciate any help you can give me.

Support My Work!

Join the wonderful group of people who have already donated. Simply buy me a coffee!

113 Cherry St #92768, Seattle, WA 98104-2205
Unsubscribe · Preferences

Tommy's Outdoors: Conservation and Science

I am an outdoorsman, podcaster and speaker. I talk and write about the natural environment, biodiversity, conservation, hunting and fishing, rewilding and more. I am particularly interested in wildlife and human-wildlife interactions. I enjoy reading scientific papers on those subjects as much as being outdoors weathering the elements and getting first-hand experiences.

Read more from Tommy's Outdoors: Conservation and Science
Podcast episode cover art featuring two men in a split-screen format against a green background. On the left, a guest wearing a baseball cap and dark zip-up hoodie sits indoors with framed pictures visible on the wall behind him. On the right, the podcast

Conservation and Science Fair warning folks, this might be a controversial one for some of you. I got in touch with today's guest after a listener contacted me following one of the previous episodes. Shout out to Rod and thank you! In the end, the episode isn't about what Rod had suggested, though I think the topic is no less interesting. While talking to Ryan, I knew we were going to discuss a topic that is highly controversial and one I dealt with back in the day in episode 76. Some people...

Podcast episode cover featuring two men in a split-screen video call format. On the left, a middle-aged man with greying hair and beard wearing a salmon-coloured t-shirt sits in an indoor setting with framed wildlife photographs visible on the wall behind

Conservation and Science The topic of interactions between beavers and salmon was something I wanted to cover for some time. The most interesting aspect for me was that anglers are usually on the side of nature, conservation and restoration. In this case however, anglers were the group who weren't so keen on the return of beavers to British rivers, despite the unequivocal benefits beavers bring to ecosystems. How strange! Sometimes the "boots on the ground" attitude might be the source of...

Podcast cover art featuring two men in a split-screen format against a green background. On the left, a young man with curly brown hair wearing black-rimmed glasses and a light blue shirt, speaking into a microphone with headphones on, positioned in what

Conservation and Science This issue of the newsletter is fully dedicated to the latest episode of the podcast and to the book that sparked the idea for this episode. There are several reasons why I consider this book special. First, the topic, or more precisely, the group of birds this book discusses. It's not a comprehensive, dry, scientific description. You should treat this book like field notes of sorts. I enjoyed reading a book in this format, especially as I've discussed the topic of...